Simplifying Financial Management with Expense Tracking Tools

While the basic GST system in New Zealand is straightforward, many businesses encounter situations that require special treatment or adjustments. Understanding these special cases is essential for accurate GST compliance and avoiding unexpected tax liabilities.

Change of Use Adjustments

When Change of Use Occurs

A change of use adjustment is required when assets are used for a different purpose than originally intended:

• Business assets that begin to be used privately
• Private assets that begin to be used for business
• Assets that shift between taxable and exempt activities
• Changes in the proportion of business vs. private use
• Assets originally acquired for resale that are retained for business use

These changes trigger GST adjustment obligations to reflect the asset's actual use over time.

The Adjustment Process

For standard change of use adjustments:

• Calculate the difference between actual use and intended use
• Determine whether additional GST is payable or refundable
• Report the adjustment in the relevant GST return
• Maintain records supporting the adjustment calculation
• Consider whether ongoing periodic adjustments will be required

The adjustment ensures the GST outcome reflects the actual use of the asset.

Adjustment Periods

The number of adjustment periods depends on the asset's value:

• For assets valued under $5,000, usually just one adjustment period
• For assets valued between $5,000 and $10,000, two adjustment periods
• For assets valued between $10,000 and $500,000, five adjustment periods
• For land and assets over $500,000, ten adjustment periods

These periods spread significant adjustments over time, reducing the immediate impact.

Mixed-Use Assets

Identifying Mixed-Use Assets

Mixed-use assets are used for both business and private purposes:

• Vehicles used for both business and personal travel
• Home offices in residential properties
• Computers and electronic devices
• Holiday homes or boats rented commercially and used privately
• Equipment occasionally loaned for private use

The dual nature of these assets requires special GST treatment.

Apportionment Methods

Several methods can be used to apportion GST for mixed-use assets:

• For vehicles: logbook records, mileage calculations, or standard percentage
• For home offices: floor area calculations or usage-based assessment
• For electronic devices: time-based usage records or reasonable estimate
• For holiday homes: specific rules under the mixed-use asset legislation
• For general equipment: time-based usage or output-based measures

The chosen method should be fair, reasonable, and consistently applied.

Record-Keeping Requirements

Supporting documentation for mixed-use assets includes:

• Evidence of the asset's cost and GST paid
• Records supporting the apportionment method (logbooks, floor plans, etc.)
• Calculations showing how the business percentage was determined
• Documentation of changes in usage patterns
• Records of adjustment calculations made over time

These records are essential if Inland Revenue reviews your GST position.

GST and Private Use Adjustments

Business Assets Used Privately

When business assets are used privately:

• Output tax must be accounted for on the private use portion
• The value is typically based on the cost of providing the private benefit
• Regular private use creates ongoing adjustment obligations
• Common examples include business vehicles used for personal travel
• Special rules apply to assets that are both business premises and dwellings

These adjustments ensure GST is paid on the private consumption element.

Goods Taken for Private Use

When business inventory is taken for private use:

• This creates a deemed supply subject to GST
• The value is typically the cost of the goods
• GST must be accounted for as output tax
• Common in retail businesses where owners use their own products
• Similar rules apply to services provided to owners or employees

Regular withdrawals of inventory should be systematically tracked for GST purposes.

Private Assets Used for Business

When private assets are introduced to a business:

• A second-hand goods input tax credit may be available
• The credit is calculated as 3/23 of the lesser of cost or market value
• Documentation of the asset's value is required
• Adjustments may be needed if business use increases over time
• Special rules apply to land and buildings

This allows businesses to claim GST on assets introduced from non-GST environments.

GST Adjustments for Bad Debts

Writing Off Bad Debts

When customers fail to pay invoices:

• GST can be claimed back when the debt is written off
• This only applies if GST was previously returned on the sale
• The debt must be genuinely written off in the accounting records
• Reasonable steps must have been taken to recover the debt
• The adjustment is claimed in the GST return for the period of write-off

This relief prevents businesses from paying GST on sales revenue they never receive.

Subsequent Recovery of Bad Debts

If a written-off debt is later recovered:

• GST must be returned on the amount recovered
• This applies even to partial recoveries
• The adjustment is made in the return for the period of recovery
• Records should link the recovery to the original write-off
• The GST component is calculated as 3/23 of the amount recovered

This ensures the GST position is corrected if the financial outcome changes.

Accounting for Bad Debt Adjustments

Effective systems for bad debt adjustments include:

• Clear procedures for identifying and documenting bad debts
• Formal write-off processes with appropriate approvals
• Tracking of GST claimed on bad debts
• Monitoring of potential recoveries
• Regular reconciliation of bad debt GST adjustments

These systems help ensure all eligible relief is claimed while maintaining compliance.

GST Adjustments for Insurance Proceeds

Business Assets Insurance Claims

When insurance proceeds are received for business assets:

• Insurance payments for damaged or lost business assets are generally subject to GST
• This creates output tax that must be accounted for
• The timing is generally when the claim is settled
• The GST treatment should match the original asset's GST treatment
• Replacement assets will have their own GST implications

Insurance settlements effectively "monetize" the remaining GST component of the asset.

Business Interruption Insurance

For business interruption claims:

• Payments to compensate for lost revenue are generally subject to GST
• Payments for specific non-taxable costs may have different treatment
• The GST liability arises when the claim is settled
• Documentation should clearly identify the nature of the compensation
• The GST treatment should be addressed in the claim process

The GST treatment follows the nature of what the payment is replacing.

Insurance Excess Payments

When businesses pay insurance excesses:

• GST is generally claimable on excess payments for business assets
• The excess payment must relate to a business asset or expense
• Documentation should show the business nature of the claim
• Mixed-use assets may require apportionment
• The excess is treated as a business expense for GST purposes

This reflects the business nature of the underlying insurance arrangement.

GST and Hire Purchase Arrangements

GST Treatment of Hire Purchase

For assets acquired through hire purchase:

• GST is generally claimable upfront on the cash price of the asset
• This differs from operating leases where GST is claimed on each payment
• Finance charges are typically exempt from GST as financial services
• The supplier accounts for GST on the cash price at the beginning
• Documentation should clearly separate the cash price from finance charges

This treatment reflects that hire purchase is effectively an immediate acquisition with deferred payment.

Adjustments for Early Termination

If a hire purchase agreement is terminated early:

• Additional charges may be subject to GST
• Rebates of finance charges typically have no GST effect
• The supplier may need to make GST adjustments
• The purchaser generally doesn't need to adjust input tax already claimed
• Documentation should clearly identify the nature of termination payments

The GST treatment follows the nature of the termination arrangements.

Record-Keeping for Hire Purchase

Maintain these records for hire purchase arrangements:

• The original hire purchase agreement showing the cash price
• Tax invoices supporting the GST claim
• Documentation of the business use of the asset
• Records of any early termination arrangements
• Evidence of any change of use over time

These records support the GST treatment if questioned by Inland Revenue.

GST Adjustments for Price Changes

Credit Notes and Adjustments

When prices are reduced after invoicing:

• Credit notes should be issued for price reductions or returns
• The supplier can claim back GST on the reduction amount
• The customer must reduce their input tax claim accordingly
• The adjustment is made in the return for the period of the credit note
• Credit notes should reference the original supply

This ensures GST reflects the final transaction value.

Discounts and Rebates

For various forms of discounts:

• Prompt payment discounts taken reduce the GST-inclusive price
• Volume rebates paid retrospectively require GST adjustments
• Loyalty rewards and discounts typically reduce the GST value
• Group purchasing rebates may have specific GST implications
• Documentation should clearly establish the nature of the discount

The GST treatment should match the commercial reality of the price reduction.

Price Increases and Additional Charges

When prices are increased after initial invoicing:

• Additional tax invoices should be issued for the increase
• The supplier must account for GST on the additional amount
• The customer can claim additional input tax accordingly
• The timing follows standard time of supply rules
• Documentation should link the increase to the original supply

This ensures GST is paid on the full final value of the transaction.

GST on Cancellation Fees and Compensation

Contract Cancellation Payments

When customers pay to cancel contracts:

• Cancellation fees are generally subject to GST
• This applies even if no goods or services are actually provided
• The fee is typically treated as consideration for the original supply
• Documentation should clearly identify the nature of the payment
• Special rules may apply for specific industries or arrangements

The GST treatment follows the contractual nature of the cancellation arrangement.

Liquidated Damages and Penalties

For contractual damages and penalties:

• Liquidated damages specified in contracts are generally subject to GST
• Statutory penalties may have different GST treatment
• Court-awarded damages require specific analysis
• The key test is whether the payment relates to a taxable supply
• Documentation should clearly establish the nature of the payment

The GST treatment depends on the relationship to underlying supplies.

Compensation and Settlements

For compensation payments and settlements:

• Payments for damaged or defective goods typically attract GST
• Compensation for poor service is generally subject to GST
• Pure damages unrelated to supplies may be outside the GST system
• Settlement agreements should address GST treatment
• Documentation should clearly identify what the payment represents

Careful analysis is required to determine the correct GST treatment based on what the payment represents.

GST on Vouchers and Gift Cards

Basic GST Treatment

For vouchers, gift cards, and similar instruments:

• GST is generally not payable when vouchers are issued
• GST becomes payable when vouchers are redeemed for goods or services
• The GST treatment follows the goods or services provided on redemption
• Face-value vouchers create specific timing considerations
• Discounted sales of vouchers have special GST implications

This treatment recognizes that vouchers themselves are not the final supply.

Unredeemed Vouchers

When vouchers expire without being redeemed:

• The treatment depends on whether consideration was received for the voucher
• For vouchers sold, GST may become payable when they expire
• For promotional vouchers issued free, no GST typically applies
• Records should track expiry and redemption status
• Policies for handling breakage should address GST implications

The GST outcome should reflect the economic reality of the arrangement.

Multi-Purpose Vouchers

For vouchers redeemable for different types of supplies:

• GST treatment depends on the actual goods or services provided on redemption
• Different GST rates may apply to different redemption options
• Record-keeping should track the GST treatment of redemptions
• Systems should correctly calculate GST based on the actual redemption
• Accounting systems should handle the GST timing appropriately

The final GST treatment follows the nature of the goods or services ultimately provided.

GST and Barter Transactions

Identifying Barter Transactions

Barter occurs when goods or services are exchanged without monetary payment:

• Direct exchanges of goods or services
• Countertrade arrangements
• Payment through provision of goods or services
• Exchanges facilitated by barter exchanges or trade dollars
• Part-exchange arrangements (part payment, part goods/services)

These non-monetary exchanges still create GST obligations.

GST Treatment of Barter

For GST purposes:

• Barter transactions are treated as two separate supplies
• Each party makes a taxable supply to the other
• The value is typically the open market value of the goods or services
• Both parties must account for GST output tax on their supply
• Both parties may claim input tax on what they receive (if for taxable use)

This ensures GST neutrality regardless of whether payment is monetary.

Valuation and Documentation

For barter transactions:

• Determine the market value of each side of the exchange
• Issue tax invoices based on this value
• Document how the value was determined
• Maintain records of both sides of the transaction
• Account for GST based on the documented values

Good documentation is essential to support the GST treatment of non-monetary exchanges.

GST for Specific Industries

Second-Hand Goods Dealers

Special rules apply to second-hand goods dealers:

• Input tax credits can be claimed on purchases from non-registered persons
• The credit is calculated as 3/23 of the purchase price
• Detailed records of purchases from non-registered persons must be kept
• Special rules apply to associated person transactions
• GST must be charged on the full selling price

These provisions ensure GST is collected on the dealer's margin while preventing double taxation.

Financial Services Providers

Financial services have specific GST treatment:

• Most financial services are exempt from GST
• This means no GST is charged, but input tax generally can't be claimed
• Some financial services to non-residents may be zero-rated
• Mixed supplies require apportionment of input tax
• Special rules apply to unit trusts and similar investment vehicles

These complex rules reflect the difficulty of applying GST to financial intermediation.

Travel and Tourism Operators

For businesses in the travel and tourism sector:

• Domestic tourism services are subject to standard GST rules
• Services consumed outside New Zealand may qualify for zero-rating
• Special rules apply to tour packages that include both domestic and international elements
• Facilitation services for overseas tourism may have specific GST treatment
• Record-keeping should clearly separate different elements of packages

These provisions reflect the destination principle underlying New Zealand's GST system.

Correcting GST Errors

Types of GST Errors

Common GST errors that require correction include:

• Calculation errors in GST returns
• Timing errors (reporting in the wrong period)
• Classification errors (incorrect GST treatment)
• Omissions of transactions
• Duplicate claims or returns
• Errors in apportionment or adjustment calculations

Identifying and correcting these errors promptly reduces penalty risk.

Correction Thresholds and Process

The process for correcting GST errors depends on their magnitude:

• Errors under $1,000 in GST can generally be corrected in the next GST return
• Larger errors typically require a voluntary disclosure to Inland Revenue
• Material errors may require amendment of previously filed returns
• Timing errors often correct themselves in the next period
• Systematic errors affecting multiple periods need comprehensive correction

The correction approach should match the nature and significance of the error.

Documentation and Systems Improvement

When correcting GST errors:

• Document the nature of the error
• Record how it was discovered
• Detail the correction method used
• Implement system improvements to prevent recurrence
• Consider whether similar errors might exist elsewhere

Treating errors as learning opportunities improves overall GST compliance.

Conclusion

GST adjustments and special cases add complexity to New Zealand's GST system, but with proper understanding and systems, they can be managed effectively. The key to successful management of these situations is recognizing when special rules apply and implementing appropriate processes to ensure compliance.

By maintaining good records, documenting the basis for adjustments, and seeking professional advice for complex situations, businesses can navigate these special cases with confidence. Remember that many of these adjustments are designed to ensure GST ultimately reflects the actual use of goods and services in the taxable activity, maintaining the integrity of the GST system.

While the specific rules for different adjustments vary, the underlying principle remains consistent: GST should be paid on the value of goods and services consumed in New Zealand, with businesses acting as collection agents rather than bearing the ultimate cost. Understanding these special cases helps ensure this principle is maintained even in complex business scenarios.